Just Pray Harder?

Seeking treatment doesn't mean that you don't believe.

Karen Staaats

10/30/20266 min read

woman praying
woman praying

I'm not exactly sure when I learned that if I just prayed harder, everything would be OK. I think that lesson was brought home each time I heard a sermon that seemed to imply that all we needed was enough faith and everything in our lives would be fixed. I'm not saying that was the message the preachers intended to send. But somewhere along the way, I absorbed the idea that if I believed strongly enough, prayed long enough, and trusted God completely enough, my depression would go away.

And when it didn't, I wondered what was wrong with me.

There is a culture in some churches that suggests faith can overcome anything. And I understand where that belief comes from. We serve a God who can do anything. But somewhere between believing that God can heal us and believing that He must heal us if we have enough faith, we can lose sight of something important.

Now, don't get me wrong. I believe the Scriptures. I believe Jesus when He talks about faith the size of a mustard seed. I believe the promise to seek and find. I know that God is real. I know that God is listening. And I know that God loves me. But I also know that Paul prayed three times for his affliction to be removed, and God didn't remove it. Instead, He told Paul, "My grace is sufficient for thee: for my strength is made perfect in weakness" (2 Corinthians 12:9, KJV).

I've thought about that Scripture a great deal over the years. Paul wasn't lacking faith. He wasn't doing something wrong. He was asking God for relief from something that caused him suffering. And God's answer wasn't the answer Paul had hoped for.

That doesn't mean God loved Paul any less. It took me a long time to understand that not being cured of my depression didn't mean I lacked faith, either.

There are still people in the church who will tell you that if you just believe enough, pray enough, or surrender enough, your depression will disappear. I believe that comes from a misunderstanding of what faith really means. Needing treatment for depression doesn't mean you're failing spiritually. It means you're dealing with an illness and doing what you can to get better.

And sometimes doing what you can means taking medication, seeing a therapist, or trying a treatment you never imagined you would need.

I know we're not all in the same place on this journey. Some of us are avoiding treatment because we've been taught that seeking help means we aren't depending on God. Others are already receiving treatment but carry a quiet shame about it. We sit in church, sing the hymns, listen to the sermon, and never mention that we're taking medication just to make it through the day.

I wonder how many women are sitting in church pews every Sunday feeling exactly that way. I wonder how many are smiling and saying they're fine while privately questioning whether their depression is evidence of some spiritual failure.

I know what that feels like.

For a long time, I didn't seek the help I needed because I had been taught that I shouldn't need it. There was a very close loved one in my life who told me point blank, “Karen, if you’re depressed, you’re not saved.” He told me my depression was all in my head, and if I just prayed harder and increased my faith, I would be OK. Because of that, I believed that seeking treatment would mean I had turned my back on God. So, I kept trying to do what I thought a good Christian woman was supposed to do.

I prayed. I believed. I waited.

And I was still depressed.

What I wish someone had told me back then is that faith and treatment were never opposing choices. It wasn't an either/or question. I didn't have to choose between trusting God and accepting medical help.

Think about it. We don't ordinarily tell someone with a broken leg to pray instead of going to the doctor. We don't accuse someone with diabetes of lacking faith because they need insulin. Yet somehow, when the illness involves our minds, we begin to question whether medical treatment is really necessary.

Depression is an illness that can affect our thoughts, emotions, sleep, energy, and physical health. It deserves to be taken seriously, just as any other illness does.

I also understand that some of the people who gave me that advice genuinely believed they were helping. They were repeating what they had been taught. They loved God, and many of them loved me. But people can love us and still give us advice that hurts.

I've had to learn that I can respect someone's faith without accepting their understanding of my illness. And I can love someone without allowing their opinions to determine whether I receive treatment.

My own journey through depression has been long. I've seen counselors and psychiatrists. I've tried medications and different forms of treatment. Some things helped. Some didn't. There were times when I wondered whether I would ever find anything that made a difference.

But I kept going.

And something happened along the way that I hadn't expected.

My faith grew stronger.

As treatment began to help lift some of the fog I'd lived in for so many years, I found that I could see God more clearly. I wasn't looking at Him through quite the same haze of despair. I began to see my life as a life worth living rather than a tragedy I was simply enduring.

I could look back and recognize the ways God had been with me all along. He hadn't abandoned me during the years when I was struggling. He hadn't turned away when I walked into a psychiatrist's office or swallowed another pill. He was there through every medication, every treatment option, and every disappointment.

He's still here with me in my current treatment.

I can truly say that I'm closer to God now than I've ever been. Not because my depression has magically disappeared. It hasn't. I still have difficult days. I still need treatment. But I no longer believe that needing help makes me less faithful.

Prayer remains a big part of my life. When I was in the depths of depression, sometimes the only prayer I could manage was, "God, help me." Other times, I poured out my heart with all its fears, doubts, anger, and contradictions.

I've never been particularly good at fancy prayers. For me, prayer is simply talking to God the way I'm talking to you. I tell Him what's troubling me. I tell Him when I'm afraid. I tell Him when I don't understand what He's doing. And I've learned that He doesn't run from those honest prayers.

Sometimes His comfort comes through Scripture. Sometimes through a friend who calls at just the right moment. And sometimes it comes through the people who have spent years learning how to treat illnesses like mine.

I don't pretend to understand why God hasn't taken my depression away. I have spent years asking that question. What I do know is that I don't have to wait until I'm healed to experience His love.

And neither do you.

If you've been struggling with the belief that taking medication or seeking counseling means your faith isn't strong enough, I hope you'll consider something. Perhaps the help you've been afraid to accept is part of the provision you've been praying for.

You don't have to make a grand announcement at church. You don't have to defend your treatment to anyone. You don't even have to know exactly what kind of help you need.

You can begin with one conversation. A doctor. A counselor. Someone you trust.

And if you're struggling so deeply that you don't know how to take that first step, please know that help is available. In the United States, you can call or text 988 to reach the Suicide & Crisis Lifeline. You don't have to be suicidal to ask for support.

I spent years believing I had to choose between my faith and my healing. I wish someone had told me sooner that I could have both.

I still pray. I still take my medication. I still have days when the fog rolls back in.

But I also have days filled with peace, laughter, and gratitude. Days when I look around and realize how much of life I would have missed if I'd given up on finding help.

And on those days, I thank God for the grace that carried me through the darkness and for the people and treatments that helped me find my way toward the light.

I didn't lose my faith when I accepted help. I found room for it to grow.